Pizza Plus

I really wanted to like this place as I try to support locally owned businesses (I convinced my wife not to go to Domino's tonight and go here instead), but unfortunately our experience wasn't a great one. The good: the pizza flavor was good with lots of toppings, the bread sticks were cheesy, the salad was nice, and the ranch and pizza sauce were good. The not so good: as you can see in the picture with the exception of one the BBQ wings were burnt beyond edible; the cookies were just partially cooked dough (the second picture of the cookies on foil is AFTER we took them back to our Airbnb and baked them for another 8 minutes and they were still very doughy); the pizza wasn't cooked through so the middle was doughy, and the wings weren't done all the way through so they were somewhat stringy and chewy; the service when we ordered the pizza was simply straightforward and neutral, when ordering the cookies it was a little better (more welcoming) - both employees that brought out our orders did it with a smile and were nice; the dining room area wasn't the cleanest and there was no A/C. I'm not sure if they were rushing food through the oven to keep up with demand but it resulted in a lot of partially cooked food for us (except for the oddly extremely overcooked BBQ wings). On a side note, there were several teenagers that were gaming in the back room, they were having fun and when they finished they cleaned up after themselves and even put the chairs upside down on the tables - we were very impressed with them!

This place has some of the best pizza I have ever eaten. We were in a rush to get dinner before everything closed and this place made the night! Pizza is not greasy and has a perfect amount of sauce as well as toppings! The sauce is so dang good!! Not sure if they made it in house but it was perfect! We ate ourselves sick cause we couldn't stop! I would travel there just to eat their pizza! My fiancee agreed. Maybe we will have them cater our small wedding! 🤷🏻

We were passing by on our way to Idaho and decided to stop by since we have heard so many great things about this place. The place itself is pretty beat up, the seats are torn and it’s not been cleaned very well. I ordered breadsticks with extra cheese and a calzone. After 30 minutes of waiting we were told that our breadsticks got overcooked and that we need to wait for new breadsticks. We said we would not wait and they offered us regular breadsticks and return the difference for cheese. My calzone had huge chunks of onion and none of the tomatoes that I paid for. The stuff is very sweet but I believe customers service could really use some improvement. I believe this could have been handled a lot better. After 30 minutes of waiting they gave me a small bag of chips to make up for their mistake. I’m all about supporting local businesses but we will not be returning.